Crate or No Crate? Let’s Talk About It


Let’s be honest — the word
crate can sound a little harsh. But for many dogs, a crate isn’t a cage. It’s a safe, cozy den where they can relax, recharge, and get a bit of peace from the chaos of human life (and the vacuum cleaner). Still, it’s not for every pup — so let’s figure out what works best for yours.

 

Is Crate Training Right for Your Dog?

✅Crates can be incredibly useful for:

  • Toilet training puppies.
  • Giving high-energy dogs a break.
  • Creating a calm space during chaos (guests, deliveries, vacuuming).
  • Keeping your dog safe when you can’t supervise

❌But crates might not be the best choice if:

  • Your dog has severe separation anxiety and panics when confined.
  • You’ve adopted a rescue with trauma around confinement.
  • Your dog gets overstimulated by being able to see everything but not access it.

 

Still not sure? Try a short test session with the door open — if your dog chooses to hang out inside, that’s a good sign. If they panic, whine, or try to escape immediately, a crate may not be the best fit right now.

 

How to Crate Train (Without Tears or Tantrums)

1. Pick the Right Crate
Choose one that’s big enough for your dog to stand, turn around, and lie down comfortably — but not so big that they use one end as a toilet. Wire crates with covers or enclosed plastic styles both work, depending on your pup’s preference.
2. Make it a Vibe
Add a soft bed, blanket, and their favourite toy (or two). Keep the crate in a low-traffic spot of the house where your pup feels safe. You want it to feel like a retreat, not a punishment.
3. Start with the Door Open
Let your dog explore the crate on their own terms. Toss in some Treatos (just make sure to supervise), feed meals nearby, or play around it. Keep it casual and low-pressure.
4. Gradual, Supervised Use Only
Begin with short, calm sessions. Encourage your pup to rest in the crate while you’re nearby. Never use it for punishment, and avoid shutting them in too quickly.
5. Keep Goodbyes Low-Key
If the crate’s part of your leaving routine, make it no big deal. Skip the drawn-out goodbyes and keep things casual — the less fuss you make, the less your pup will stress.

What If It’s Not Working?

Some dogs just don’t love crates, and that’s okay! You can try:

  • Dog-proofing a room with baby gates. 
  • Playpens for smaller or older dogs.
  • Place training, where your pup learns to chill on a mat or bed.
  • Calming routines, like music, gentle massage, or enrichment toys (again, only under supervision)

The goal is to help your dog feel safe and secure, not stressed and stuck.

 

Crate or No Crate, Comfort Comes First

Whether your pup’s snoozing in a crate or stretched out across the hallway like royalty, the key is helping them feel safe, settled, and part of the pack. Crate training can be a brilliant tool — if it fits your dog’s personality and your lifestyle.

Every dog’s different. And every home is, too. So whether you go the crate route or take another path, it’s all about finding the setup that keeps tails wagging.

 

💬 Tried crate training before? Let us know what worked for you in the comments, we’re all about swapping tips.



Back to blog

1 comment

My kelpie pup (who came from a sheep farm) HATED the crate. He’d go to sleep at first but then wake up and panic, wee, poop, scratch at the door. It was awful and I felt like a failure as many resources say to use a crate. I persevered but it never got better. My partner intervened and started to tie him up on our verandah- he cried for 10 minutes the first night and then not a peep out of him since (he’s now 7 months old).
Thankyou for saying the crates not for everyone- it definitely didn’t work for us and I wish I’d read this a few months ago and given myself (and my pup) a break that it wasn’t for us!

Sarah Smith

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.